Give Up the Gold
Mood:
bright
Now Playing: News
Topic: Sports
US gold medalist and Waukesha, WI resident
Paul Hamm was asked to give up his gold medal:
"World gymnastics officials asked Paul Hamm to give up his gold medal as the ultimate show of sportsmanship, but the U.S. Olympic Committee told them to take responsibility for their own mistakes and refused even to deliver the request."
For those of you who have missed the news concerning this, a judging error resulted in Paul Hamm being awarded the gold medal in all-around gymnastics. The South Korean who received bronze should have received a higher score and should have been awarded the gold. The South Koreans have appealed and the latest is Paul Hamm being asked to give up his medal in a show of sportsmanship.
My thoughts. First of all, I value sportsmanship. My main dislike about sports today is the in-your-face, trash-talking athlete. I understand celebration. Celebration is fine. High fiving and pile-ups by team mates is celebration. No problem. But some antics go overboard.
But, to be asked to be a good sport, especially by the organization responsible for the judging puts undo pressure on the young athlete, and does not make him a good sport.
The Olympics have long since ceased being an event where sportsmen gathered. Pressure to "win the gold" puts added pressure on judges. Politics sometimes also plays a part. The rewards for athletes who win gold are great, far beyond the gold medal itself. Paul Hamm has already appeared on David Letterman. And being a human endeavor, mistakes will happen, as did in this situation.
Then, I wonder if the international body has sent a similar letter to the South Korean, asking him to be a model of sportsmanship and accept the bronze medal. A look at replays of his routine showed mistakes that should have resulted in his score being two tenths of a point less, which would have resulted in Hamm winning the gold anyway.
If Paul Hamm had decided to give up the gold on his own, it would have been great, in my opinion. If he decides to give it up after this, greater still. But today's benefits to the gold medal winning athlete make that unlikely.
Posted by Dean
at 11:29 AM CDT